Fascinating to watch Wajda’s film the night after Pawlikowski’s. Both films set in the immediate aftermath of the Second World War, both exploring the tensions around the Soviet invasion and the possibilities of history changing course. Both feature a striking scene in a ruined church towards the end, and both benefit from some marvellous cinematography.
However, the differences are also striking. Wajda’s film is full of humour, humanity and pathos. The narrative of Ashes and Diamonds occurs over a condensed, 24 hour period, on the day that Germany formally surrendered at the end of the Second World War. During that time its protagonist, Maciek, played by the inspirational Zbigniew Cybulski, kills, flirts, has sex, falls in love, changes his mind, kills again and is finally killed. He embodies the contradictions of the immediate post-war era, the desire to put an end to politics and war, offset by the need to fight for the society that will emerge from the ruins. It’s a wonderfully complex performance in a wonderfully complex film, a thriller, a love story and a political allegory all rolled into one.
Clearly comparisons are odious, but Wajda’s film’s willingness to be messy, both in terms of its narrative and its filming style, reveals the power that cinema possesses when it’s let off the leash. There is always a requirement of control in cinema, drummed in at film schools. Yet the effect can be rigid, can make the work of art feel like something lifeless. Whilst Wajda and Jerzy Wójcik clearly went to extreme pains to set up the vast majority of shots in Ashes and Diamonds, (the horse, the crowd scenes, the bed scenes, even the opening, all of this and more are impeccably framed), the film permits chaos to infiltrate. No more so than in the closing scene, but also in the party scenes, in the bar scenes. Likewise, the narrative has space for chaos and characters, figures and moments that the economy of the story does not require, but whose presence enrich the film, and help to deepen our understanding, eighty years later, of the meaning of the events on this night, the end of one war and start of another.
Nb - We were shown this film at school, so many summers ago. Zbigniew Cybulski was the Polish James Dean, we were told. Who knows who chose to screen the film and where we even watched it. I remember bucket chairs and a portable screen being set up. The film has lingered in my consciousness for over forty years, even if the subtleties of its interrogation of the world, a world my parents already occupied, would barely have registered when I first watched it.









